loved the idea and the concept...very interesting...the lady was really convincing ! great job ! 

Well shot and well told. A very effective tragedy. You should be proud of your work. 

I like the old woman... 

I could really sense your knowledge of cinema and camera setups (like everyone's anonymity and dark faces indoors would've liked to see - in addition to the protagonist's invisibility - a real character, other than a lonely old woman. I'm happy you didn't show her actually dead (or whatever happened to her ), but again, I think you set her up with such a possibility for an interesting development and story. 

hey nice work Markus, I can sense that you didn't have enough time to tell your story.. a 3 minute limit.. does make it tought to tell stories like this.. you have to sarcrifice things to fit them in.. but i saw that you can make films.. with more time make them really good.. i wish you all the best, and would like to see more films from you.. take care. 

beautiful..that was just great ...i m fan of ur making..n cinemetography and the feel is just awesome 

Very sensitive. It moved me. Maxime Pourbaix (The Mojo) 

Beautiful and moving little film. Really well done - great work! 

Quite sad but very ture. We are losing the connection to one another. You composed some really beautiful images that told the story perfectly. Excellent work! 

possibly my favorite of all the films in the competition. universal story, great leading lady, a beautiful score, nice pace, cohesive editing. my only complaint was that it had to end after only three minutes. great work. I look forward to seeing more from you. 

I like it a lot, you are going to be in my short list. I invite you to watch the animation I did for this competition. "HELP, WANTED DEATH OR ALIVE" i couldnt finishi it for the dateline. Your coments will be my price. check it at my profile 

Sehr nette Idee und angenehme Auflösung. Außerdem guter Musikeinsatz! Da sieht man wieder, dass Köln eine Medienhauptstadt ist ;-) lg, Oliver 

Sad but beautiful. Paced very nicely, nice shots, the woman was great. Really felt her. - Alex - Virtual Vikings 

very good, markus. i really liked it. is that the actual ending? or is this a clip of a longer thing? either way i like the way it ended, because it made me feel like you (the author, the director, i don't know) was telling (the viewer) "well... we all know what happened... i don't need to show it..." and that was terribly sad -- which is good. anyway, that's the way i saw it and felt it. great work with all the shots, the actors, the sped-up montage, etc.