I enjoyed the atmosphere you created. Though I must admit that I anticipated the mirror trick. Good work.  

I really enjoyed the music. It created the perfect mood.  

Great choice of music and well acted. Nicely shot too. Please check out my film "together again" and let me know what you think. 

Great payoff. My original comment was going to be that I wanted to SEE some of the images instead of just being told a story through dialogue, but I understand now what you were going for. Cool movie. Last ten seconds make it work. 

I liked it very much and I didn't anticipate the ending at all, although I was expecting something :-) You're short-listed. Please check out my 'Backwards In Time'...  

I like the fact that it's all narration and no flashbacks. 

When creating magic, you have to get the audience to focus on one thing that is not the trick. You did that. Great Job! 

Nice job. Nice editing and great camera angle you did. Shoting is very well the music very suitable for your short film also. please check my film The Ring I'd like to read your comment about my film 

A nice monologue with a cleaver and simple pay off at the end. Well done! 

awesome film!!!!!!!!please check out "BEE IN THE WEB" and let me know ur reviews!!!!!!! 

Great ending! I liked the angle you chose for the monologue, it had a cool look to it.  

Linq, Really cool. Nice old fashioned storytelling and, of course, bonus points for using the theme Smoke & Mirrors both literally in the story and the shot. I new something was coming and you still surprised me.  

Linq, Really cool. Nice old fashioned storytelling and, of course, bonus points for using the theme Smoke & Mirrors both literally in the story and the shot. I new something was coming and you still surprised me.  

Excelent!! This is Smoke & Mirrors at its finest. You use it amazingly well. Love when he blows the smoke at the end. Most be one of my favorites and surely its shortlisted. The acting is great and you managed to make something visually extraordinary. Congratulations. Please check my film THE VISIT 

Great Job Ling!! Loved it. You got my vote!! 

Simple and sweet. Great style.